Structure vs Process - How to look at politics

Compare, contrast, and assess attempts by at least two anthropologists to analyse politics in terms of temporal processes rather than (a-temporal) structure.

Nonfiction, Reference & Language, Education & Teaching
Cover of the book Structure vs Process - How to look at politics by Johannes Lenhard, GRIN Verlag
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Johannes Lenhard ISBN: 9783656323792
Publisher: GRIN Verlag Publication: November 28, 2012
Imprint: GRIN Verlag Language: English
Author: Johannes Lenhard
ISBN: 9783656323792
Publisher: GRIN Verlag
Publication: November 28, 2012
Imprint: GRIN Verlag
Language: English

Essay from the year 2012 in the subject Pedagogy - Science, Theory, Anthropology, grade: 65, University of Cambridge, language: English, abstract: Compare, contrast, and assess attempts by at least two anthropologists to analyse politics in terms of temporal processes rather than (a-temporal) structure. Edmund Leach published his account of the Kachin society in Highland Burma in 1954, fourteen years after Evans-Pritchard's and Fortes' classical structural-functionalist collection on 'African Political Systems'. Only four years after Leach, Barth's 'Swat Pathans' enters the debate. Both Barth and Leach differ remarkably in their methodological approach fousing on change and process. While Radcliffe-Brown (Fortes & Evans-Pritchard, 2006:vi) proclaims in his preface to 'African Political Systems' that the aim of anthropology is to 'discover the universal, essential, characters which belong to all human societies, past, present and future', Leach (Leach, 2004) heavily criticises the implicit underlying assumption of equilibrium. Instead, he focuses on the study of the 'constantly changing environment' and society as 'a process in time' (ibid.:5). As I will argue his process is still very much structural, however. In contrast to structure, Barth makes individual action his centre piece that aggregates to higher political levels in temporal processes. In the following analysis, I will complement my analysis of the two core texts mentioned above with methodological writings comparing Barth's and Leach's account of political processes in Pakistan and Burma respectively.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

Essay from the year 2012 in the subject Pedagogy - Science, Theory, Anthropology, grade: 65, University of Cambridge, language: English, abstract: Compare, contrast, and assess attempts by at least two anthropologists to analyse politics in terms of temporal processes rather than (a-temporal) structure. Edmund Leach published his account of the Kachin society in Highland Burma in 1954, fourteen years after Evans-Pritchard's and Fortes' classical structural-functionalist collection on 'African Political Systems'. Only four years after Leach, Barth's 'Swat Pathans' enters the debate. Both Barth and Leach differ remarkably in their methodological approach fousing on change and process. While Radcliffe-Brown (Fortes & Evans-Pritchard, 2006:vi) proclaims in his preface to 'African Political Systems' that the aim of anthropology is to 'discover the universal, essential, characters which belong to all human societies, past, present and future', Leach (Leach, 2004) heavily criticises the implicit underlying assumption of equilibrium. Instead, he focuses on the study of the 'constantly changing environment' and society as 'a process in time' (ibid.:5). As I will argue his process is still very much structural, however. In contrast to structure, Barth makes individual action his centre piece that aggregates to higher political levels in temporal processes. In the following analysis, I will complement my analysis of the two core texts mentioned above with methodological writings comparing Barth's and Leach's account of political processes in Pakistan and Burma respectively.

More books from GRIN Verlag

Cover of the book 'Es ist besser, wenn man mehr hat'!? by Johannes Lenhard
Cover of the book Übertragungsmöglichkeiten des Toyota Production System auf den Prozess der Kreditsachbearbeitung by Johannes Lenhard
Cover of the book Der Nießbrauch an Personen- und Kapitalgesellschaftsanteilen im Gesellschafts- und Steuerrecht by Johannes Lenhard
Cover of the book Wegbereiter der Erlebnispädagogik. Von Jean-Jacques Rousseau bis Kurt Hahn by Johannes Lenhard
Cover of the book Zweisprachiges Kärnten. Eine Identitäts- und Spurensuche by Johannes Lenhard
Cover of the book Islamism, a threat for the West? by Johannes Lenhard
Cover of the book Schwimmen und Sinken. Die Experimentierbox von Cornelsen für die Grunschule by Johannes Lenhard
Cover of the book Konsolidierungstendenzen der pharmazeutischen Industrie by Johannes Lenhard
Cover of the book Der Klostersturm 1940/41 und die Gegenwehr des Bischofs von Galen by Johannes Lenhard
Cover of the book The Concept of the Grotesque from the Reneissance to the Twentieth Century. A Critical Study by Johannes Lenhard
Cover of the book Dialog - zur Qualitätssicherung im sozialpädagogischen Alltag by Johannes Lenhard
Cover of the book Entwicklungsstufen in der Kindheit bei Rousseau und aus heutiger Sicht by Johannes Lenhard
Cover of the book Sharepoint für Projektmanager by Johannes Lenhard
Cover of the book Die Nachfolge bei Tod eines Gesellschafters in einer Personengesellschaft by Johannes Lenhard
Cover of the book Eventmanagement. Ein Leitfaden zur professionellen Umsetzung von Events by Johannes Lenhard
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy