The Judiciary, Discrimination Law and Statutory Interpretation

Easy Cases Making Bad Law

Nonfiction, Reference & Language, Law, Discrimination
Cover of the book The Judiciary, Discrimination Law and Statutory Interpretation by Michael Connolly, Taylor and Francis
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Michael Connolly ISBN: 9780429834790
Publisher: Taylor and Francis Publication: August 30, 2018
Imprint: Routledge Language: English
Author: Michael Connolly
ISBN: 9780429834790
Publisher: Taylor and Francis
Publication: August 30, 2018
Imprint: Routledge
Language: English

In 1856, the US Supreme Court denied Dred Scott, now free of slavery, his Constitutional rights, solely because he was black. According to the Court, when the Constitution was drafted, some 60 years earlier, its authors would not have intended that ‘a subordinate and inferior class of beings’ qualified as citizens of the United States. Thus, the meaning of language drafted over half a century before was frozen in time.

This case, perhaps more than any other, demonstrates that the matter of statutory interpretation is critical, technical, and, sometimes, highly emotive. The case is not a mere nugget from history to indulge our disgust with values of another age, and with it a satisfaction of our progress to today’s higher moral ground. It is the unfortunate case that the senior courts of England continue to produce highly contentious interpretations of our equality and discrimination laws.

This book examines these cases from the perspective of statutory interpretation, the judge’s primary function. The scrutiny finds the judgments technically flawed, overcomplicated, excessively long, and often unduly restrictive. As such, this book explains how the cases should have been resolved – using conventional methods of interpretation; this would have produced simpler, technically sound judgments. Rather like the case of Dred Scott, these were easy cases producing bad law.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

In 1856, the US Supreme Court denied Dred Scott, now free of slavery, his Constitutional rights, solely because he was black. According to the Court, when the Constitution was drafted, some 60 years earlier, its authors would not have intended that ‘a subordinate and inferior class of beings’ qualified as citizens of the United States. Thus, the meaning of language drafted over half a century before was frozen in time.

This case, perhaps more than any other, demonstrates that the matter of statutory interpretation is critical, technical, and, sometimes, highly emotive. The case is not a mere nugget from history to indulge our disgust with values of another age, and with it a satisfaction of our progress to today’s higher moral ground. It is the unfortunate case that the senior courts of England continue to produce highly contentious interpretations of our equality and discrimination laws.

This book examines these cases from the perspective of statutory interpretation, the judge’s primary function. The scrutiny finds the judgments technically flawed, overcomplicated, excessively long, and often unduly restrictive. As such, this book explains how the cases should have been resolved – using conventional methods of interpretation; this would have produced simpler, technically sound judgments. Rather like the case of Dred Scott, these were easy cases producing bad law.

More books from Taylor and Francis

Cover of the book Engaging the Senses: Object-Based Learning in Higher Education by Michael Connolly
Cover of the book The Age of the Inquiry by Michael Connolly
Cover of the book Political Myth by Michael Connolly
Cover of the book The End of the Developmental State? by Michael Connolly
Cover of the book Better Humans? by Michael Connolly
Cover of the book Attention and Creation by Michael Connolly
Cover of the book The Child in Mind by Michael Connolly
Cover of the book Being Skilled by Michael Connolly
Cover of the book Mental Health and Social Policy, 1845-1959 by Michael Connolly
Cover of the book Conceptual Issues in Psychological Medicine by Michael Connolly
Cover of the book Third World by Michael Connolly
Cover of the book Further Selections from the Tragic History of the Sea, 1559-1565 by Michael Connolly
Cover of the book Parliaments and Citizens by Michael Connolly
Cover of the book The African American Church in Birmingham, Alabama, 1815-1963 by Michael Connolly
Cover of the book The Academic Revolution by Michael Connolly
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy