Rhetoric and The Rule of Law

A Theory of Legal Reasoning

Nonfiction, Reference & Language, Law, Religion & Spirituality, Philosophy, Social & Cultural Studies, Social Science
Cover of the book Rhetoric and The Rule of Law by Neil MacCormick, OUP Oxford
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Neil MacCormick ISBN: 9780191018787
Publisher: OUP Oxford Publication: July 28, 2005
Imprint: OUP Oxford Language: English
Author: Neil MacCormick
ISBN: 9780191018787
Publisher: OUP Oxford
Publication: July 28, 2005
Imprint: OUP Oxford
Language: English

Is legal reasoning rationally persuasive, working within a discernible structure and using recognisable kinds of arguments? Does it belong to rhetoric in this sense, or to the domain of the merely 'rhetorical' in an adversative sense? Is there any reasonable certainty about legal outcomes in dispute-situations? If not, what becomes of the Rule of Law? Neil MacCormick's book tackles these questions in establishing an overall theory of legal reasoning which shows the essential part 'legal syllogism' plays in reasoning aimed at the application of law, while acknowledging that simple deductive reasoning, though always necessary, is very rarely sufficient to justify a decision. There are always problems of relevancy, classification or interpretation in relation to both facts and law. In justifying conclusions about such problems, reasoning has to be universalistic and yet fully sensitive to the particulars of specific cases. How is this possible? Is legal justification at this level consequentialist in character or principled and right-based? Both normative coherence and narrative coherence have a part to play in justification, and in accounting for the validity of arguments by analogy. Looking at such long-discussed subjects as precedent and analogy and the interpretative character of the reasoning involved, Neil MacCormick expands upon his celebrated Legal Reasoning and Legal Theory (OUP 1978 and 1994) and restates his 'institutional theory of law'.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

Is legal reasoning rationally persuasive, working within a discernible structure and using recognisable kinds of arguments? Does it belong to rhetoric in this sense, or to the domain of the merely 'rhetorical' in an adversative sense? Is there any reasonable certainty about legal outcomes in dispute-situations? If not, what becomes of the Rule of Law? Neil MacCormick's book tackles these questions in establishing an overall theory of legal reasoning which shows the essential part 'legal syllogism' plays in reasoning aimed at the application of law, while acknowledging that simple deductive reasoning, though always necessary, is very rarely sufficient to justify a decision. There are always problems of relevancy, classification or interpretation in relation to both facts and law. In justifying conclusions about such problems, reasoning has to be universalistic and yet fully sensitive to the particulars of specific cases. How is this possible? Is legal justification at this level consequentialist in character or principled and right-based? Both normative coherence and narrative coherence have a part to play in justification, and in accounting for the validity of arguments by analogy. Looking at such long-discussed subjects as precedent and analogy and the interpretative character of the reasoning involved, Neil MacCormick expands upon his celebrated Legal Reasoning and Legal Theory (OUP 1978 and 1994) and restates his 'institutional theory of law'.

More books from OUP Oxford

Cover of the book Essentials of Dental Caries by Neil MacCormick
Cover of the book The Animal Kingdom: A Very Short Introduction by Neil MacCormick
Cover of the book Computing with Cells by Neil MacCormick
Cover of the book Training in Medicine by Neil MacCormick
Cover of the book The Making of Modern Turkey by Neil MacCormick
Cover of the book African History: A Very Short Introduction by Neil MacCormick
Cover of the book The Quest for Reality: Bohr and Wittgenstein - two complementary views by Neil MacCormick
Cover of the book Roman Britain: A Very Short Introduction by Neil MacCormick
Cover of the book Jesus and the Chaos of History by Neil MacCormick
Cover of the book The Oxford Handbook of the Sources of International Law by Neil MacCormick
Cover of the book Selected Letters by Neil MacCormick
Cover of the book European Banking Union by Neil MacCormick
Cover of the book Dryden and Enthusiasm by Neil MacCormick
Cover of the book Confronting the Shadow State by Neil MacCormick
Cover of the book The Governance Report 2015 by Neil MacCormick
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy