Plato's Doctrine Respecting the Rotation of the Earth and Aristotle's Comment Upon That Doctrine

Nonfiction, Religion & Spirituality, New Age, History, Fiction & Literature
Cover of the book Plato's Doctrine Respecting the Rotation of the Earth and Aristotle's Comment Upon That Doctrine by George Grote, Library of Alexandria
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: George Grote ISBN: 9781465613349
Publisher: Library of Alexandria Publication: March 8, 2015
Imprint: Language: English
Author: George Grote
ISBN: 9781465613349
Publisher: Library of Alexandria
Publication: March 8, 2015
Imprint:
Language: English
The obscurity of this passage is amply attested by the numerous differences of opinion to which it has given rise, both in ancient and in modern times. Various contemporaries of Plato (νιοι — Aristot. De Coelo, II. 13, p. 293 b. 30) understood it as asserting or implying the rotatory movement of the earth in the centre of the Kosmos, and adhered to this doctrine as their own. Aristotle himself alludes to these contemporaries without naming them, and adopts their interpretation of the passage; but dissents from the doctrine, and proceeds to impugn it by arguments. Cicero mentions (Academic II. 39) that there were persons who believed Plato to have indicated the same doctrine obscurely, in his Timaeus: this passage must undoubtedly be meant. Plutarch devotes a critical chapter to the enquiry, what was Plato’s real doctrine as to the cosmical function of the earth — its movement or rest (Quaestion. Platonic. VII. 3, p. 1006.) There exists a treatise, in Doric dialect, entitled Τίμαίω τ Λόκρω Περ Ψυχς Κόσμω κα Φύσιος, which is usually published along with the works of Plato. This treatise was supposed in ancient times to be a genuine production of the Lokrian Timaeus, whom Plato introduces as his spokesman in the dialogue so called. As such, it was considered to be of much authority in settling questions of interpretation as to the Platonic Timaeus. But modern critics hold, I believe unanimously, that it is the work of some later Pythagorean or Platonist, excerpted or copied from the Platonic Timaeus. This treatise represents the earth as being in the centre and at rest. But its language, besides being dark and metaphorical, departs widely from the phraseology of the Platonic Timaeus: especially in this — that it makes no mention of the cosmical axis, nor of the word λλομένην or ελουμένην. Alexander of Aphrodisias (as we learn from Simplikius ad Aristot. De Coelo, fol. 126) followed the construction of Plato given by Aristotle. “It was improbable (he said) that Aristotle could be ignorant either what the word signified, or what was Plato’s purpose” (λλ τ ριστοτέλει, φησν, οτω λέγοντιλλεσθαι, οκ ελογον ντιλέγειν· ς ληθς γρ οτε τς λέξεως τ σημαινόμενον εκς ν γνοεν ατν, οτε τν Πλάτωνος σκοπόν. This passage is not given in the Scholia of Brandis). Alexander therefore construed λλομένην as meaning or implying rotatory movement, though in so doing he perverted (so Simplikius says) the true meaning to make it consonant with his own suppositions.
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
The obscurity of this passage is amply attested by the numerous differences of opinion to which it has given rise, both in ancient and in modern times. Various contemporaries of Plato (νιοι — Aristot. De Coelo, II. 13, p. 293 b. 30) understood it as asserting or implying the rotatory movement of the earth in the centre of the Kosmos, and adhered to this doctrine as their own. Aristotle himself alludes to these contemporaries without naming them, and adopts their interpretation of the passage; but dissents from the doctrine, and proceeds to impugn it by arguments. Cicero mentions (Academic II. 39) that there were persons who believed Plato to have indicated the same doctrine obscurely, in his Timaeus: this passage must undoubtedly be meant. Plutarch devotes a critical chapter to the enquiry, what was Plato’s real doctrine as to the cosmical function of the earth — its movement or rest (Quaestion. Platonic. VII. 3, p. 1006.) There exists a treatise, in Doric dialect, entitled Τίμαίω τ Λόκρω Περ Ψυχς Κόσμω κα Φύσιος, which is usually published along with the works of Plato. This treatise was supposed in ancient times to be a genuine production of the Lokrian Timaeus, whom Plato introduces as his spokesman in the dialogue so called. As such, it was considered to be of much authority in settling questions of interpretation as to the Platonic Timaeus. But modern critics hold, I believe unanimously, that it is the work of some later Pythagorean or Platonist, excerpted or copied from the Platonic Timaeus. This treatise represents the earth as being in the centre and at rest. But its language, besides being dark and metaphorical, departs widely from the phraseology of the Platonic Timaeus: especially in this — that it makes no mention of the cosmical axis, nor of the word λλομένην or ελουμένην. Alexander of Aphrodisias (as we learn from Simplikius ad Aristot. De Coelo, fol. 126) followed the construction of Plato given by Aristotle. “It was improbable (he said) that Aristotle could be ignorant either what the word signified, or what was Plato’s purpose” (λλ τ ριστοτέλει, φησν, οτω λέγοντιλλεσθαι, οκ ελογον ντιλέγειν· ς ληθς γρ οτε τς λέξεως τ σημαινόμενον εκς ν γνοεν ατν, οτε τν Πλάτωνος σκοπόν. This passage is not given in the Scholia of Brandis). Alexander therefore construed λλομένην as meaning or implying rotatory movement, though in so doing he perverted (so Simplikius says) the true meaning to make it consonant with his own suppositions.

More books from Library of Alexandria

Cover of the book The Complete Works of Winston Churchill by George Grote
Cover of the book The Eye of Dread by George Grote
Cover of the book Where the Twain Meet by George Grote
Cover of the book Poesie Scelte by George Grote
Cover of the book Two Wars: An Autobiography of General Samuel Gibbs French Mexican War; War between the States, a Diary; Reconstruction Period, His Experience; Incidents, Reminiscences, etc. by George Grote
Cover of the book The Beauties of Nature and the Wonders of the World We Live In by George Grote
Cover of the book In Touch with Nature: Tales and Sketches from the Life by George Grote
Cover of the book Absolute Spirit by George Grote
Cover of the book The Census in Moscow by George Grote
Cover of the book Arabella by George Grote
Cover of the book Thomas Carlyle by George Grote
Cover of the book Oriente by George Grote
Cover of the book On the Art of Reading by George Grote
Cover of the book The Cries of London: Exhibiting Several of The Itinerant Traders of Antient and Modern Times by George Grote
Cover of the book The Origin of the World According to Revelation and Science by George Grote
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy