The Supreme Court against the Criminal Jury

Social Science and the Palladium of Liberty

Nonfiction, History, European General, Social & Cultural Studies, Political Science, Government, Americas, United States
Cover of the book The Supreme Court against the Criminal Jury by John A. Murley, Sean D. Sutton, Lexington Books
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: John A. Murley, Sean D. Sutton ISBN: 9780739136232
Publisher: Lexington Books Publication: June 12, 2014
Imprint: Lexington Books Language: English
Author: John A. Murley, Sean D. Sutton
ISBN: 9780739136232
Publisher: Lexington Books
Publication: June 12, 2014
Imprint: Lexington Books
Language: English

The Supreme Court against the Criminal Jury: Social Science and the Palladium of Liberty is an analysis of the United States Supreme Court decisions in what has come to be called the “jury-size” and “jury-decision rule” cases. In Williams v. Florida (1970) and Ballew v. Georgia (1978), a majority of the Supreme Court looked to history, empirical studies, and functional analysis to support its claim that there was “no discernible difference” between the verdicts of juries of six and juries of twelve. In the process the Court also decided that the number twelve was an historical accident and that the twelve-member jury was not an essential ingredient of trial by jury.

Two years later, the Court, following essentially the same line of reasoning used in Williams, decided in the companion cases Apodaca v. Oregon (1972) and Johnson v. Louisiana (1972) that defendants were as well served with juries that reached verdicts by a majority vote of 11-1,10-2 and 9-3 as they were with unanimous jury verdicts. In these cases the Supreme Court rejected the centuries old common law view that the unanimous jury verdict was an essential element of trial by jury. With these four decisions, the criminal jury as it had been known for more than six hundred years under the common law and the Constitution was in principle abandoned. We critique these decisions from the perspective of unreliable jury studies and the impact of these decision on jury nullification.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

The Supreme Court against the Criminal Jury: Social Science and the Palladium of Liberty is an analysis of the United States Supreme Court decisions in what has come to be called the “jury-size” and “jury-decision rule” cases. In Williams v. Florida (1970) and Ballew v. Georgia (1978), a majority of the Supreme Court looked to history, empirical studies, and functional analysis to support its claim that there was “no discernible difference” between the verdicts of juries of six and juries of twelve. In the process the Court also decided that the number twelve was an historical accident and that the twelve-member jury was not an essential ingredient of trial by jury.

Two years later, the Court, following essentially the same line of reasoning used in Williams, decided in the companion cases Apodaca v. Oregon (1972) and Johnson v. Louisiana (1972) that defendants were as well served with juries that reached verdicts by a majority vote of 11-1,10-2 and 9-3 as they were with unanimous jury verdicts. In these cases the Supreme Court rejected the centuries old common law view that the unanimous jury verdict was an essential element of trial by jury. With these four decisions, the criminal jury as it had been known for more than six hundred years under the common law and the Constitution was in principle abandoned. We critique these decisions from the perspective of unreliable jury studies and the impact of these decision on jury nullification.

More books from Lexington Books

Cover of the book NATO by John A. Murley, Sean D. Sutton
Cover of the book American Green by John A. Murley, Sean D. Sutton
Cover of the book Echoes from the Poisoned Well by John A. Murley, Sean D. Sutton
Cover of the book Dissent and Philosophy in the Middle Ages by John A. Murley, Sean D. Sutton
Cover of the book Sons of the Fathers by John A. Murley, Sean D. Sutton
Cover of the book Poor America by John A. Murley, Sean D. Sutton
Cover of the book Theology and Public Philosophy by John A. Murley, Sean D. Sutton
Cover of the book Social Theory for Old and New Modernities by John A. Murley, Sean D. Sutton
Cover of the book Escaping Servitude by John A. Murley, Sean D. Sutton
Cover of the book Theodore Roosevelt and the Art of American Power by John A. Murley, Sean D. Sutton
Cover of the book Central Asian Cultures, Arts, and Architecture by John A. Murley, Sean D. Sutton
Cover of the book Tolerance and Modern Liberalism by John A. Murley, Sean D. Sutton
Cover of the book The "Other" Karen in Myanmar by John A. Murley, Sean D. Sutton
Cover of the book Resilience in South Sudanese Women by John A. Murley, Sean D. Sutton
Cover of the book Frames and Connections in the Governance of Global Communications by John A. Murley, Sean D. Sutton
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy