Infamy

Nonfiction, Social & Cultural Studies, Political Science, Government, Public Affairs & Administration
Cover of the book Infamy by T. J. Hill, T. J. Hill
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: T. J. Hill ISBN: 9781311768919
Publisher: T. J. Hill Publication: October 26, 2015
Imprint: Smashwords Edition Language: English
Author: T. J. Hill
ISBN: 9781311768919
Publisher: T. J. Hill
Publication: October 26, 2015
Imprint: Smashwords Edition
Language: English

Infamy discusses Kennedy’s murder, and the 9/11 attacks, to understand grounds for true belief in politics. Three questions ensue: 1) What shapes political opinions, in particular beliefs about consequential political crimes? 2) How do we distinguish truth from untruth in politics? 3) How do we sort true beliefs from all the other judgments we may develop about political events?

Experimentation to test hypotheses helps scientists sort what we know from what we do not. Investigators who want to know the truth about political crimes make good use of hypotheses and evidence, but they must work backward in time to discover why the crime unfolded as it did. That means they cannot apply strictly experimental methods to the questions they investigate.

We know that both crimes – Kennedy’s murder and the events of 9/11 – generate monumental disagreements about who committed them. We also disagree about valid methods to reconcile contradictory accounts. These disagreements suggest that even if scientific standards of truth and forensic methods of investigation apply, they do not compel conclusions for crimes like these. When you observe conflict this fundamental, where people disagree not only about what happened, but also about how to reach judgments in the matter, you have an epistemic problem difficult to resolve.

New Orleans district attorney Jim Garrison quoted, “Let justice be done though the heavens fall,” as he investigated Kennedy’s murder in the 1960s. Garrison met opposition and ridicule as he pursued his case. When the heavens fall, the calamity affects everyone. From the story of Oedipus the king until this day, open inquiry into political crimes entails high stakes for the whole community. You cannot know, when you start, where your investigation will lead, what the outcome will be, what consequences you will suffer, or what may befall others. You merely trust that truth yields a better outcome than untruth.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

Infamy discusses Kennedy’s murder, and the 9/11 attacks, to understand grounds for true belief in politics. Three questions ensue: 1) What shapes political opinions, in particular beliefs about consequential political crimes? 2) How do we distinguish truth from untruth in politics? 3) How do we sort true beliefs from all the other judgments we may develop about political events?

Experimentation to test hypotheses helps scientists sort what we know from what we do not. Investigators who want to know the truth about political crimes make good use of hypotheses and evidence, but they must work backward in time to discover why the crime unfolded as it did. That means they cannot apply strictly experimental methods to the questions they investigate.

We know that both crimes – Kennedy’s murder and the events of 9/11 – generate monumental disagreements about who committed them. We also disagree about valid methods to reconcile contradictory accounts. These disagreements suggest that even if scientific standards of truth and forensic methods of investigation apply, they do not compel conclusions for crimes like these. When you observe conflict this fundamental, where people disagree not only about what happened, but also about how to reach judgments in the matter, you have an epistemic problem difficult to resolve.

New Orleans district attorney Jim Garrison quoted, “Let justice be done though the heavens fall,” as he investigated Kennedy’s murder in the 1960s. Garrison met opposition and ridicule as he pursued his case. When the heavens fall, the calamity affects everyone. From the story of Oedipus the king until this day, open inquiry into political crimes entails high stakes for the whole community. You cannot know, when you start, where your investigation will lead, what the outcome will be, what consequences you will suffer, or what may befall others. You merely trust that truth yields a better outcome than untruth.

More books from Public Affairs & Administration

Cover of the book The Trusted Leader by T. J. Hill
Cover of the book Japan's Foreign and Security Policy in the Twenty First Century: Challenges and Alternatives by T. J. Hill
Cover of the book Los retos de la gestión del agua en la Ciudad de México by T. J. Hill
Cover of the book A History of the University of Manchester, 1973–90 by T. J. Hill
Cover of the book Development of Environmental Laws and Jurisprudence in Pakistan by T. J. Hill
Cover of the book JOURNEY THROUGH UTOPIA by T. J. Hill
Cover of the book Ma Xiangbo and the Mind of Modern China by T. J. Hill
Cover of the book Engendering Governance Institutions by T. J. Hill
Cover of the book Der Reformprozess in der Ukraine 2014-2017 by T. J. Hill
Cover of the book Public Administration's Final Exam by T. J. Hill
Cover of the book Parties, Governments and Voters in Finland by T. J. Hill
Cover of the book Catalytic Governance by T. J. Hill
Cover of the book L’evoluzione dei controlli nell’Amministrazione Pubblica by T. J. Hill
Cover of the book 11 Reasons to Thank President Trump by T. J. Hill
Cover of the book Public Values and Public Interest by T. J. Hill
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy