Transparency and Self-Knowledge

Nonfiction, Religion & Spirituality, Philosophy, Epistemology, Mind & Body
Cover of the book Transparency and Self-Knowledge by Alex Byrne, OUP Oxford
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Alex Byrne ISBN: 9780192554741
Publisher: OUP Oxford Publication: April 19, 2018
Imprint: OUP Oxford Language: English
Author: Alex Byrne
ISBN: 9780192554741
Publisher: OUP Oxford
Publication: April 19, 2018
Imprint: OUP Oxford
Language: English

Alex Byrne sets out and defends a theory of self-knowledge-knowledge of one's mental states. Inspired by Gareth Evans' discussion of self-knowledge in his The Varieties of Reference, the basic idea is that one comes to know that one is in a mental state M by an inference from a worldly or environmental premise to the conclusion that one is in M. (Typically the worldly premise will not be about anything mental.) The mind, on this account, is 'transparent': self-knowledge is achieved by an 'outward glance' at the corresponding tract of the world, not by an 'inward glance' at one's own mind. Belief is the clearest case, with the inference being from 'p' to 'I believe that p'. One serious problem with this idea is that the inference seems terrible, because 'p' is at best very weak evidence that one believes that p. Another is that the idea seems not to generalize. For example, what is the worldly premise corresponding to 'I intend to do this', or 'I feel a pain'? Byrne argues that both problems can be solved, and explains how the account covers perception, sensation, desire, intention, emotion, memory, imagination, and thought. The result is a unified theory of self-knowledge that explains the epistemic security of beliefs about one's mental states (privileged access), as well as the fact that one has a special first-person way of knowing about one's mental states (peculiar access).

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

Alex Byrne sets out and defends a theory of self-knowledge-knowledge of one's mental states. Inspired by Gareth Evans' discussion of self-knowledge in his The Varieties of Reference, the basic idea is that one comes to know that one is in a mental state M by an inference from a worldly or environmental premise to the conclusion that one is in M. (Typically the worldly premise will not be about anything mental.) The mind, on this account, is 'transparent': self-knowledge is achieved by an 'outward glance' at the corresponding tract of the world, not by an 'inward glance' at one's own mind. Belief is the clearest case, with the inference being from 'p' to 'I believe that p'. One serious problem with this idea is that the inference seems terrible, because 'p' is at best very weak evidence that one believes that p. Another is that the idea seems not to generalize. For example, what is the worldly premise corresponding to 'I intend to do this', or 'I feel a pain'? Byrne argues that both problems can be solved, and explains how the account covers perception, sensation, desire, intention, emotion, memory, imagination, and thought. The result is a unified theory of self-knowledge that explains the epistemic security of beliefs about one's mental states (privileged access), as well as the fact that one has a special first-person way of knowing about one's mental states (peculiar access).

More books from OUP Oxford

Cover of the book The End of the Timeless God by Alex Byrne
Cover of the book The Iliad by Alex Byrne
Cover of the book The Healing Virtues by Alex Byrne
Cover of the book Investment Banking by Alex Byrne
Cover of the book Bad Queen Bess? by Alex Byrne
Cover of the book The Bible and Feminism by Alex Byrne
Cover of the book Who Cares about Particle Physics? by Alex Byrne
Cover of the book Brentano's Mind by Alex Byrne
Cover of the book Iran: A Very Short Introduction by Alex Byrne
Cover of the book Brokerage and Closure by Alex Byrne
Cover of the book Blackstone's Criminal Practice 2019 by Alex Byrne
Cover of the book The Brain as a Tool by Alex Byrne
Cover of the book Scriptural Authority and Biblical Criticism in the Dutch Golden Age by Alex Byrne
Cover of the book Seeing, Knowing, Understanding by Alex Byrne
Cover of the book Origins of the Colonnaded Streets in the Cities of the Roman East by Alex Byrne
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy