The Ends of Harm

The Moral Foundations of Criminal Law

Nonfiction, Reference & Language, Law, Religion & Spirituality, Philosophy, Social & Cultural Studies, Social Science
Cover of the book The Ends of Harm by Victor Tadros, OUP Oxford
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Victor Tadros ISBN: 9780191018411
Publisher: OUP Oxford Publication: September 15, 2011
Imprint: OUP Oxford Language: English
Author: Victor Tadros
ISBN: 9780191018411
Publisher: OUP Oxford
Publication: September 15, 2011
Imprint: OUP Oxford
Language: English

Every modern democratic state imprisons thousands of offenders every year, depriving them of their liberty, causing them a great deal of psychological and sometimes physical harm. Relationships are destroyed, jobs are lost, the risk of the offender being harmed by other offenders is increased and all at great expense to the state. How can this brutal and costly enterprise be justified? Traditionally, philosophers answering this question have argued either that the punishment of wrongdoers is a good in itself (retributivism), or that it is a regrettable means to a valuable end, such as the deterrence of future wrongdoing, and thus justifiable on consequentialist grounds. This book offers a critical examination of those theories and advances a new argument for punishment's justification, calling it the 'duty view'. On this view, the permission to punish offenders is grounded in the duties that they incur in virtue of their wrongdoing. The most important duties that ground the justification of punishment are the duty to recognize that the offender has done wrong and the duty to protect others against wrongdoing. In the light of these duties the state has a permission to punish offenders to ensure that they recognize that what they have done is wrong, but also to protect others from crime. In contrast to other justifications of punishment grounded in deterrence, the duty view is developed in the light of a non-consequentialist moral theory: a theory which endorses constraints on the pursuit of the good. It is shown that it is normally wrong to harm a person as a means to pursue a greater good. However, there are exceptions to this principle in cases where the person harmed has an enforceable duty to pursue the good. The implications of this idea are explored both in the context of self-defence, and then in the context of punishment. Through the systematic exploration of the relationship between self-defence and punishment, the book makes significant progress in defending a plausible set of non-consequentialist moral principles that justify the punishment of wrongdoers, and marks a significant contribution to the philosophical literature on punishment.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

Every modern democratic state imprisons thousands of offenders every year, depriving them of their liberty, causing them a great deal of psychological and sometimes physical harm. Relationships are destroyed, jobs are lost, the risk of the offender being harmed by other offenders is increased and all at great expense to the state. How can this brutal and costly enterprise be justified? Traditionally, philosophers answering this question have argued either that the punishment of wrongdoers is a good in itself (retributivism), or that it is a regrettable means to a valuable end, such as the deterrence of future wrongdoing, and thus justifiable on consequentialist grounds. This book offers a critical examination of those theories and advances a new argument for punishment's justification, calling it the 'duty view'. On this view, the permission to punish offenders is grounded in the duties that they incur in virtue of their wrongdoing. The most important duties that ground the justification of punishment are the duty to recognize that the offender has done wrong and the duty to protect others against wrongdoing. In the light of these duties the state has a permission to punish offenders to ensure that they recognize that what they have done is wrong, but also to protect others from crime. In contrast to other justifications of punishment grounded in deterrence, the duty view is developed in the light of a non-consequentialist moral theory: a theory which endorses constraints on the pursuit of the good. It is shown that it is normally wrong to harm a person as a means to pursue a greater good. However, there are exceptions to this principle in cases where the person harmed has an enforceable duty to pursue the good. The implications of this idea are explored both in the context of self-defence, and then in the context of punishment. Through the systematic exploration of the relationship between self-defence and punishment, the book makes significant progress in defending a plausible set of non-consequentialist moral principles that justify the punishment of wrongdoers, and marks a significant contribution to the philosophical literature on punishment.

More books from OUP Oxford

Cover of the book Shakespeare and the Middle Ages by Victor Tadros
Cover of the book The Fragile Brain by Victor Tadros
Cover of the book The Oxford Handbook of the Archaeology of Death and Burial by Victor Tadros
Cover of the book Mind, Brain, and Free Will by Victor Tadros
Cover of the book Ulysses by Victor Tadros
Cover of the book Relativity: A Very Short Introduction by Victor Tadros
Cover of the book Simple Sentences, Substitution, and Intuitions by Victor Tadros
Cover of the book Romanticism: A Very Short Introduction by Victor Tadros
Cover of the book Tourette Syndrome by Victor Tadros
Cover of the book Science Fiction: A Very Short Introduction by Victor Tadros
Cover of the book The Emperor's New Mind by Victor Tadros
Cover of the book Approaching the Roman Revolution by Victor Tadros
Cover of the book The Vision of Didymus the Blind by Victor Tadros
Cover of the book Making Amulets Christian by Victor Tadros
Cover of the book Nationalism and Social Policy by Victor Tadros
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy