Learning from Our Military History: The United States Army, Operation Iraqi Freedom, and the Potential for Operational Art and Thinking - Petraeus, COIN, Clausewitz, Counterinsurgency

Nonfiction, History, Military, Vietnam War, Asian
Cover of the book Learning from Our Military History: The United States Army, Operation Iraqi Freedom, and the Potential for Operational Art and Thinking - Petraeus, COIN, Clausewitz, Counterinsurgency by Progressive Management, Progressive Management
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Progressive Management ISBN: 9781311405371
Publisher: Progressive Management Publication: October 26, 2014
Imprint: Smashwords Edition Language: English
Author: Progressive Management
ISBN: 9781311405371
Publisher: Progressive Management
Publication: October 26, 2014
Imprint: Smashwords Edition
Language: English

How was the US Army successful in OIF? Some tactical organizations, companies included, learned and adapted, whereas others accomplished little and made the environment worse. The interviews conducted as part of the Scholar's Program and personal reflections confirmed that a deeper and more historical understanding is required. OIF demonstrated the need for operational art and thinking, particularly in commanders of relatively junior rank. After all the effort expended in Iraq, we may ultimately fail in crafting our own military history in OIF in breadth and depth. This thesis offers an explanation on how we learned and adapted in OIF, not for the purposes of a definitive military history, but only as an intellectual way point that may lead us to useful military history for the future of the Army.

Many of the current accounts of the Army's efforts in OIF rely on a baseline claim, at times assumed, on an historical argument roughly described as the rejection thesis. The rejection thesis has roots in the end of the Vietnam War, and its consequences extended into OIF. This thesis argues that Army deliberately rejected counterinsurgency, in theory and practice, following Vietnam. The moral arguments for rejection of counterinsurgency emanated from a visceral reaction to the war and the tremendous amount of resources devoted towards a losing effort. In the end, the Army bore the heaviest cost during the war as well as the brunt of the political and public opprobrium following its end. The Army barely escaped from the aftermath of Vietnam. Thus, equating counterinsurgency as Vietnam enabled the Army and its leaders to cast off COIN with the war itself, returning the thinking on war and warfare to its proper sphere, conventional land battle in Europe, where the true strategic interest lay.

CHAPTER 1 - INTRODUCTION * CHAPTER 2 - DOCTRINE, HISTORY, AND OPERATIONAL ART * The Necessity of Military History for Command Leadership * Contemporary Arguments Surrounding Counterinsurgency Doctrine * Is Doctrine Consequential? * The U.S. Army Experience in OIF * Clausewitz on Education and Developing Commanders * Rule Breakers: The Genius and the Talented * Divergent Philosophy on the Role of Doctrine: Generals DePuy and Cushman * CHAPTER 3 - OPERATIONAL ART IN COUNTERINSURGENCY * Operational Art in U.S. Army Doctrine and in COIN * General Sir Frank Kitson on Theory and Practice: A Synopsis * Kitson on Operational Art in COIN: The Four Requirements of a Campaign * Kitson on the Essential Capability in COIN, and War in General * Operational Art in Recent COIN History: A Black Hole * Methods and Tactics in Counterinsurgency * CHAPTER 4 - OPERATION IRAQI FREEDOM: A WAR OF MANAGEMENT * Operation Iraqi Freedom: A Synopsis * Preparing for Deployment: Taking Bureaucracy to War * The Surge in Context: Towards a Better Equilibrium * CHAPTER 5 - EDUCTION FROM DIRECT EXPERIENCE: GENERAL THOUGHTS ON LEARNING ORGANIZATIONS IN OIF * Command Leadership and Learning Organizations * Learning Organizations in OIF: Whither the Military Staff? * The Impulse to Learning, Adaptation, and Innovation * Command Leadership and Climate: The Keystone of the Learning Organization * Commander Traits and the Learning Organization * Learning in Action: One Common Thread * Mission Command in OIF or Simply an Environment of Autonomy? * Environmental Truths in OIF: Reconciling Inconsistency in Belief and Practice * Operationalizing the Learning Organization: Deviance and Innovation * The Fundamental Requirement for Tactical Organizations in COIN: Basic Fighting Competence * CHAPTER 6 - THE PROFESSION OF ARMS, MILITARY HISTORY, AND THE POTENTIAL FOR OPERATIONAL ART AND THINKING * On the Utility of Doctrine * COIN Doctrine and its Place * Overcoming Tradition and Culture Through Education * Education as the Means to Fix Military Culture * Conclusion: The Imperative of Operational Art and Thinking * FOOTNOTES * BIBLIOGRAPHY

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

How was the US Army successful in OIF? Some tactical organizations, companies included, learned and adapted, whereas others accomplished little and made the environment worse. The interviews conducted as part of the Scholar's Program and personal reflections confirmed that a deeper and more historical understanding is required. OIF demonstrated the need for operational art and thinking, particularly in commanders of relatively junior rank. After all the effort expended in Iraq, we may ultimately fail in crafting our own military history in OIF in breadth and depth. This thesis offers an explanation on how we learned and adapted in OIF, not for the purposes of a definitive military history, but only as an intellectual way point that may lead us to useful military history for the future of the Army.

Many of the current accounts of the Army's efforts in OIF rely on a baseline claim, at times assumed, on an historical argument roughly described as the rejection thesis. The rejection thesis has roots in the end of the Vietnam War, and its consequences extended into OIF. This thesis argues that Army deliberately rejected counterinsurgency, in theory and practice, following Vietnam. The moral arguments for rejection of counterinsurgency emanated from a visceral reaction to the war and the tremendous amount of resources devoted towards a losing effort. In the end, the Army bore the heaviest cost during the war as well as the brunt of the political and public opprobrium following its end. The Army barely escaped from the aftermath of Vietnam. Thus, equating counterinsurgency as Vietnam enabled the Army and its leaders to cast off COIN with the war itself, returning the thinking on war and warfare to its proper sphere, conventional land battle in Europe, where the true strategic interest lay.

CHAPTER 1 - INTRODUCTION * CHAPTER 2 - DOCTRINE, HISTORY, AND OPERATIONAL ART * The Necessity of Military History for Command Leadership * Contemporary Arguments Surrounding Counterinsurgency Doctrine * Is Doctrine Consequential? * The U.S. Army Experience in OIF * Clausewitz on Education and Developing Commanders * Rule Breakers: The Genius and the Talented * Divergent Philosophy on the Role of Doctrine: Generals DePuy and Cushman * CHAPTER 3 - OPERATIONAL ART IN COUNTERINSURGENCY * Operational Art in U.S. Army Doctrine and in COIN * General Sir Frank Kitson on Theory and Practice: A Synopsis * Kitson on Operational Art in COIN: The Four Requirements of a Campaign * Kitson on the Essential Capability in COIN, and War in General * Operational Art in Recent COIN History: A Black Hole * Methods and Tactics in Counterinsurgency * CHAPTER 4 - OPERATION IRAQI FREEDOM: A WAR OF MANAGEMENT * Operation Iraqi Freedom: A Synopsis * Preparing for Deployment: Taking Bureaucracy to War * The Surge in Context: Towards a Better Equilibrium * CHAPTER 5 - EDUCTION FROM DIRECT EXPERIENCE: GENERAL THOUGHTS ON LEARNING ORGANIZATIONS IN OIF * Command Leadership and Learning Organizations * Learning Organizations in OIF: Whither the Military Staff? * The Impulse to Learning, Adaptation, and Innovation * Command Leadership and Climate: The Keystone of the Learning Organization * Commander Traits and the Learning Organization * Learning in Action: One Common Thread * Mission Command in OIF or Simply an Environment of Autonomy? * Environmental Truths in OIF: Reconciling Inconsistency in Belief and Practice * Operationalizing the Learning Organization: Deviance and Innovation * The Fundamental Requirement for Tactical Organizations in COIN: Basic Fighting Competence * CHAPTER 6 - THE PROFESSION OF ARMS, MILITARY HISTORY, AND THE POTENTIAL FOR OPERATIONAL ART AND THINKING * On the Utility of Doctrine * COIN Doctrine and its Place * Overcoming Tradition and Culture Through Education * Education as the Means to Fix Military Culture * Conclusion: The Imperative of Operational Art and Thinking * FOOTNOTES * BIBLIOGRAPHY

More books from Progressive Management

Cover of the book 2013 National Gang Report: Street, Prison, Outlaw Motorcycle, Drug Trafficking, Organized Crime, Weapons, Explosives, Eme, Mexican Mafia, Bloods, Crips, Latin Kings, OMG, BCF, Los Zetas, Pagans by Progressive Management
Cover of the book The 71F Advantage: Applying Army Research Psychology for Health and Performance Gains - Eye Injuries, Mental Health, Suicide, Chemical and Bio Defense, Nuclear Psychological Effects, Special Ops by Progressive Management
Cover of the book 21st Century Understanding Cancer Toolkit: Radiation Therapy and Treatment, Side Effect Management, External, Internal, IMRT, Brachytherapy - Information for Patients, Families, Caregivers by Progressive Management
Cover of the book Apollo and America's Moon Landing Program: Apollo 12 Official NASA Mission Reports and Press Kit - 1969 Second Lunar Landing by Astronauts Conrad, Gordon, and Bean by Progressive Management
Cover of the book Lt. General Ned Almond, U.S. Army: A Ground Commander's Conflicting View with Airmen over CAS Doctrine and Employment - Close Air Support in World War I, II, Korean War, Command and Control by Progressive Management
Cover of the book 21st Century U.S. Military Documents: Contingency Water System Installation and Operation (Air Force Handbook 10-222) - Sewage, Latrine, Kitchen Systems, Wastewater by Progressive Management
Cover of the book Breaking the Mold: Tanks in the Cities - Five Case Studies: Sherman Tanks in World War II, Streets of Aachen, Pattons to the Rescue in Vietnam, Beirut in 1984, Grozny 1995, Fallujah in Iraq War 2004 by Progressive Management
Cover of the book 21st Century FEMA Study Course: Emergency Support Function #2 Communications (IS-802) - FCC, Cyber Incidents, NCRCG Coordination Group by Progressive Management
Cover of the book U.S. Marines in Battle: The Battle of An-Nasiriyah, Iraq and An-Nasiriyah on the Eve of War - March 23 to April 2, 2003, Task Force Tarawa, PFC Jessica Lynch, Ambush Alley by Progressive Management
Cover of the book Flights of Discovery - 50 Years at the NASA Dryden Flight Research Center (DFRC) - X-Planes, X-15, Lifting Bodies, Jet-Powered Research, Winglets, X-29, Fly-by-Wire, Lunar Landing LLRV, Space Shuttle by Progressive Management
Cover of the book Mind-Sets and Missiles: A First Hand Account of the Cuban Missile Crisis - Detailed Chronology of Intelligence Failures and Successes, President Kennedy and the Soviet Missiles in Cuba by Progressive Management
Cover of the book A Handbook of Aerospace Defense Organization 1946-1980: History of the Air Defense Command and the Aerospace Defense Command - Air Defense in World War I and II, Cold War Era, Squadrons by Progressive Management
Cover of the book 21st Century Peacekeeping and Stability Operations Institute (PKSOI) Papers - Mass Atrocity: Prevention and Response - A Mass Atrocity Response Operations (MARO) Workshop Report by Progressive Management
Cover of the book Strategic Attack of National Electrical Systems: Generation, Transmission, Distribution, Past Attacks in World War II Germany and Japan, U.S. Strategic Bombing Survey, Korea, Vietnam, Desert Storm by Progressive Management
Cover of the book Saturn V: America's Apollo Moon Rocket by Progressive Management
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy