Electing Judges

The Surprising Effects of Campaigning on Judicial Legitimacy

Nonfiction, Social & Cultural Studies, Political Science, Government, Elections
Cover of the book Electing Judges by James L. Gibson, University of Chicago Press
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: James L. Gibson ISBN: 9780226291109
Publisher: University of Chicago Press Publication: September 20, 2012
Imprint: University of Chicago Press Language: English
Author: James L. Gibson
ISBN: 9780226291109
Publisher: University of Chicago Press
Publication: September 20, 2012
Imprint: University of Chicago Press
Language: English

In Electing Judges, leading judicial politics scholar James L. Gibson responds tothe growing chorus of critics who fear that the politics of running for office undermine judicial independence and even the rule of law. While many people have opinions on the topic, few have supported them with actual empirical evidence. Gibson rectifies this situation, offering the most systematic and comprehensive study to date of the impact of campaigns on public perceptions of fairness, impartiality, and the legitimacy of elected state courts—and his findings are both counterintuitive and controversial.

 

Gibson finds that ordinary Americans do not conclude from campaign promises that judges are incapable of making impartial decisions. Instead, he shows, they understand the process of deciding cases to be an exercise in policy making, rather than of simply applying laws to individual cases—and consequently think it’s important for candidates to reveal where they stand on important issues. Negative advertising also turns out to have a limited effect on perceptions of judicial legitimacy, though the same cannot be said for widely hated campaign contributions.

 

Taking both the good and bad into consideration, Gibson argues persuasively that elections are ultimately beneficial in boosting the institutional legitimacy of courts, despite the slight negative effects of some campaign activities. Electing Judges will initiate a lively debate inside both the halls of justice and the academy.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

In Electing Judges, leading judicial politics scholar James L. Gibson responds tothe growing chorus of critics who fear that the politics of running for office undermine judicial independence and even the rule of law. While many people have opinions on the topic, few have supported them with actual empirical evidence. Gibson rectifies this situation, offering the most systematic and comprehensive study to date of the impact of campaigns on public perceptions of fairness, impartiality, and the legitimacy of elected state courts—and his findings are both counterintuitive and controversial.

 

Gibson finds that ordinary Americans do not conclude from campaign promises that judges are incapable of making impartial decisions. Instead, he shows, they understand the process of deciding cases to be an exercise in policy making, rather than of simply applying laws to individual cases—and consequently think it’s important for candidates to reveal where they stand on important issues. Negative advertising also turns out to have a limited effect on perceptions of judicial legitimacy, though the same cannot be said for widely hated campaign contributions.

 

Taking both the good and bad into consideration, Gibson argues persuasively that elections are ultimately beneficial in boosting the institutional legitimacy of courts, despite the slight negative effects of some campaign activities. Electing Judges will initiate a lively debate inside both the halls of justice and the academy.

More books from University of Chicago Press

Cover of the book Life Atomic by James L. Gibson
Cover of the book The Voice Imitator by James L. Gibson
Cover of the book National Duties by James L. Gibson
Cover of the book The Emotions of Protest by James L. Gibson
Cover of the book Darkness Visible by James L. Gibson
Cover of the book The Shape of Life by James L. Gibson
Cover of the book A Place That Matters Yet by James L. Gibson
Cover of the book Theories of Translation by James L. Gibson
Cover of the book Crime and Justice, Volume 41 by James L. Gibson
Cover of the book Snowbird by James L. Gibson
Cover of the book Abductive Analysis by James L. Gibson
Cover of the book The Sex Education Debates by James L. Gibson
Cover of the book Montesquieu and the Despotic Ideas of Europe by James L. Gibson
Cover of the book The Music between Us by James L. Gibson
Cover of the book Egyptian Oedipus by James L. Gibson
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy