Crime, Punishment and Disease in a Relativistic Universe

Nonfiction, Religion & Spirituality, Philosophy, Political, Social & Cultural Studies, Social Science, Crimes & Criminals, Criminology
Cover of the book Crime, Punishment and Disease in a Relativistic Universe by Antony Flew, Taylor and Francis
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Antony Flew ISBN: 9781351525008
Publisher: Taylor and Francis Publication: February 6, 2018
Imprint: Routledge Language: English
Author: Antony Flew
ISBN: 9781351525008
Publisher: Taylor and Francis
Publication: February 6, 2018
Imprint: Routledge
Language: English

In Crime, Punishment and Disease, Antony Flew makes clear both the meaning and the implications carried by the application of the expression "mental disease." He aims to discourage its use in conditions that provide the victims of such diseases with an excuse for failing to perform what would have been their imperative duties had they enjoyed good mental health. Flew attacks the gross over-extensions of the notion of mental disease on both sides of the Atlantic. He defends human dignity and responsibility against the suggestion that we are all, or most of us, "sick, sick, sick." In particular, he challenges the paternalist pretensions of people who claim a right to control and manipulate others because they are allegedly sick, and consequently not responsible for what they do.In a typical ordinary disease, Flew notes, it is the patient who complains of the disease rather than someone else who complains about the patient. But those who claim that some crime or all crime is symptomatic of mental disease and those who identify disorders such as attention/deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) as conditions requiring psychiatric attention are taking the disfavored behavior rather than the distress of their patients as the warrant for supposedly medical interventions. They should instead first consider how what they propose to call mental disease does, and does not, resemble syphilis, measles, and other communicable diseases.Flew sees his work as complementary to Thomas Szasz's. He applies a philosophical perspective to problems Szasz discusses as a psychiatrist. This work will be of particular interest to students of philosophy and politics, in that it relates modern discussion of mental illness to the Plato of The Republic. Flew also takes note in this context of Samuel Butler's Erewhon. This work will be of direct relevance to criminologists, as well as those interested in social welfare, philosophy of education, and new developments in psychiatry.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

In Crime, Punishment and Disease, Antony Flew makes clear both the meaning and the implications carried by the application of the expression "mental disease." He aims to discourage its use in conditions that provide the victims of such diseases with an excuse for failing to perform what would have been their imperative duties had they enjoyed good mental health. Flew attacks the gross over-extensions of the notion of mental disease on both sides of the Atlantic. He defends human dignity and responsibility against the suggestion that we are all, or most of us, "sick, sick, sick." In particular, he challenges the paternalist pretensions of people who claim a right to control and manipulate others because they are allegedly sick, and consequently not responsible for what they do.In a typical ordinary disease, Flew notes, it is the patient who complains of the disease rather than someone else who complains about the patient. But those who claim that some crime or all crime is symptomatic of mental disease and those who identify disorders such as attention/deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) as conditions requiring psychiatric attention are taking the disfavored behavior rather than the distress of their patients as the warrant for supposedly medical interventions. They should instead first consider how what they propose to call mental disease does, and does not, resemble syphilis, measles, and other communicable diseases.Flew sees his work as complementary to Thomas Szasz's. He applies a philosophical perspective to problems Szasz discusses as a psychiatrist. This work will be of particular interest to students of philosophy and politics, in that it relates modern discussion of mental illness to the Plato of The Republic. Flew also takes note in this context of Samuel Butler's Erewhon. This work will be of direct relevance to criminologists, as well as those interested in social welfare, philosophy of education, and new developments in psychiatry.

More books from Taylor and Francis

Cover of the book Literacy and Development by Antony Flew
Cover of the book Africans in Britain by Antony Flew
Cover of the book Poetry Today by Antony Flew
Cover of the book Geographies of Health, Disease and Well-being by Antony Flew
Cover of the book Integrated Approaches to Drug and Alcohol Problems by Antony Flew
Cover of the book Encrypted Messages in Alban Berg's Music by Antony Flew
Cover of the book Longman Companion to the First World War by Antony Flew
Cover of the book Globalization, Marginalization and Development by Antony Flew
Cover of the book Contemporary Patterns of Politics, Praxis, and Culture by Antony Flew
Cover of the book Child Care in Context by Antony Flew
Cover of the book Organised Crime and the Challenge to Democracy by Antony Flew
Cover of the book Developmental and Life-course Criminological Theories by Antony Flew
Cover of the book Democratic Learning by Antony Flew
Cover of the book Muslim Institutions by Antony Flew
Cover of the book The Critical Villager by Antony Flew
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy