Colonial Discourse and Gender in U.S. Criminal Courts

Cultural Defenses and Prosecutions

Nonfiction, Social & Cultural Studies, Social Science, Gender Studies, Political Science, Government
Cover of the book Colonial Discourse and Gender in U.S. Criminal Courts by Caroline Braunmühl, Taylor and Francis
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Caroline Braunmühl ISBN: 9781136341168
Publisher: Taylor and Francis Publication: August 6, 2012
Imprint: Routledge Language: English
Author: Caroline Braunmühl
ISBN: 9781136341168
Publisher: Taylor and Francis
Publication: August 6, 2012
Imprint: Routledge
Language: English

The occurrence in some criminal cases of "cultural defenses" on behalf of "minority" defendants has stirred much debate. This book is the first to illuminate how "cultural evidence" — i.e., "evidence" regarding ethnicity — is actually negotiated by attorneys, expert/lay witnesses, and defendants in criminal trials. Caroline Braunmühl demonstrates that this has occurred, overwhelmingly, in ways shaped by colonialist and patriarchal discourses common in the Western world. She argues that the controversy regarding the legitimacy of a "cultural defense" has tended to obscure this fact, and has been biased against minorities as well as all women from its inception, in the very terms in which the question for debate has been framed.

This study also breaks new ground by analyzing the strategies, and the failures, in which colonialist and patriarchal constructions of cultural evidence are resisted or — more commonly — colluded in by opposing attorneys, witnesses, and defendants themselves. The constructions at hand emerge as contradictory and unstable, belying the notion that cultural evidence is a matter of objective "information" about another culture, rather than — as Braunmühl argues — of discourses that are inevitably normatively charged.

Colonial Discourse and Gender in US Criminal Courts moves the debate about cultural defenses onto an entirely new plane, one based upon the understanding that only in-depth empirical analyses informed by critical, rigorous theoretical reflection can do justice to the irreducibly political character of any discussion of "cultural evidence," and of its presentation in court.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

The occurrence in some criminal cases of "cultural defenses" on behalf of "minority" defendants has stirred much debate. This book is the first to illuminate how "cultural evidence" — i.e., "evidence" regarding ethnicity — is actually negotiated by attorneys, expert/lay witnesses, and defendants in criminal trials. Caroline Braunmühl demonstrates that this has occurred, overwhelmingly, in ways shaped by colonialist and patriarchal discourses common in the Western world. She argues that the controversy regarding the legitimacy of a "cultural defense" has tended to obscure this fact, and has been biased against minorities as well as all women from its inception, in the very terms in which the question for debate has been framed.

This study also breaks new ground by analyzing the strategies, and the failures, in which colonialist and patriarchal constructions of cultural evidence are resisted or — more commonly — colluded in by opposing attorneys, witnesses, and defendants themselves. The constructions at hand emerge as contradictory and unstable, belying the notion that cultural evidence is a matter of objective "information" about another culture, rather than — as Braunmühl argues — of discourses that are inevitably normatively charged.

Colonial Discourse and Gender in US Criminal Courts moves the debate about cultural defenses onto an entirely new plane, one based upon the understanding that only in-depth empirical analyses informed by critical, rigorous theoretical reflection can do justice to the irreducibly political character of any discussion of "cultural evidence," and of its presentation in court.

More books from Taylor and Francis

Cover of the book New Directions in Campaigns and Elections by Caroline Braunmühl
Cover of the book The Social Theory of Georg Simmel by Caroline Braunmühl
Cover of the book Sir Thomas Gresham and Gresham College by Caroline Braunmühl
Cover of the book Philosophy, Neuroscience and Consciousness by Caroline Braunmühl
Cover of the book Korea Briefing by Caroline Braunmühl
Cover of the book African Traditions in the Study of Religion in Africa by Caroline Braunmühl
Cover of the book Grappling with Grief by Caroline Braunmühl
Cover of the book A Sociological History of the British Sociological Association by Caroline Braunmühl
Cover of the book Body Talk by Caroline Braunmühl
Cover of the book Working Subjects in Early Modern English Drama by Caroline Braunmühl
Cover of the book Governing the World Economy by Caroline Braunmühl
Cover of the book The Subject of Prostitution by Caroline Braunmühl
Cover of the book Social Limits to Economic Theory by Caroline Braunmühl
Cover of the book Getting the Message by Caroline Braunmühl
Cover of the book Population Growth and Planning Policy by Caroline Braunmühl
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy